Adversarial design review (wf_aa6fb661-e25; 22 agents, 0 failures) over the world-model
proposal + ground-truth code raised 18 findings (12 CONFIRMED + 6 PARTIAL, 0 refuted) and
caught real design-breakers before any code:
- DP-1/RS-1 (HIGH): the seed model was self-contradictory (RunMapMath regenerates the WHOLE
graph per seed, incompatible with a persistent pinned prefix) -> split: graph topology is
a pure function of WorldSeed ONLY; DescentSalt re-knots content; pinning freezes PinnedSalt.
- NR-2/RS-3 (HIGH): salvaged respawn warps a dead Wick to base -> splits the co-located party
-> in-pocket death; warp gated behind party-wipe; revive is new code, not salvage.
- DP-2 (HIGH): born-correct restore is per-entry lazy replay, not a boot one-shot.
- NR-1 phantom-kill CombatFeedback fix; NR-3 enemy wind-up gated on the light-union;
RS-2 RegionTag->PocketTag is a ~23-site semantic rewrite, not a rename.
World_Model_Build_Spec.md = the review-hardened contract (all 18 folded, findings ledger,
build order, open risks). DR-049 records the decision. Spike -> reviewed; proposal -> superseded.
New forks parked (dark-contact policy, lantern placement, END-1/EB-1 mothball timing).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
kronic
fc31d066d0