Docs: melee feel forks 1-6 implementation log + guidelines fork table marked shipped

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

Docs/Vault/02_Game_Design/Combat_Attack_Feel_Guidelines.md

@@ -213,13 +213,15 @@ anticipation floors per G1; one **signature silhouette pose** per kind's windup
 
 | # | Fork | Recommendation | Status |
 |---|---|---|---|
-| 1 | **Damage at contact tick** (G2.1) — light melee gains ~0.2 s real windup | DO — it's the honest heavy-weapon model; feel-test behind a knob | ☐ operator |
-| 2 | **Reach retune** (G2.2) — `MeleeRange` 2.6→2.2, finisher reach ×1.5→×1.25 | DO with #1 as one package | ☐ operator |
-| 3 | **Weapon scale ×1.25 + tip trail** (G2.3) | DO — cheapest honesty win | ☐ operator |
-| 4 | Victim-vibrate + finisher hold ladder (G5) | DO — pure presentation | ☐ operator |
-| 5 | Input buffer 6–10t (G7) — a small predicted-sim change | DO after #1 lands (same system) | ☐ operator |
-| 6 | Class cancel policies (G7) — Bathynaut commit / Harpooner crisp | Ratify as design law | ☐ operator |
+| 1 | **Damage at contact tick** (G2.1) — light melee gains ~0.2 s real windup | DO — it's the honest heavy-weapon model; feel-test behind a knob | ✅ SHIPPED 07-20 (`MeleeCleavePending` schedule-and-consume; knob `MeleeContactTicks`, 0 = legacy) |
+| 2 | **Reach retune** (G2.2) — `MeleeRange` 2.6→2.2, finisher reach ×1.5→×1.25 | DO with #1 as one package | ✅ SHIPPED 07-20 (`MeleeFinisherRangeMult` knob 30) |
+| 3 | **Weapon scale ×1.25 + tip trail** (G2.3) | DO — cheapest honesty win | ✅ SHIPPED 07-20 (axe ×1.25; blade-smear ribbon; arc reveal ends AT contact) |
+| 4 | Victim-vibrate + finisher hold ladder (G5) | DO — pure presentation | ✅ hold ladder SHIPPED (`FinisherHoldFrames`); **vibrate CUT** — Rukhanka folds the render child's inverse transform into skinning, an offset is a no-op (review C8); follow-up = additive anim layer |
+| 5 | Input buffer 6–10t (G7) — a small predicted-sim change | DO after #1 lands (same system) | ✅ SHIPPED 07-20 (`BufferedAttackTick` GhostField; unlock-edge validity, batch-slack 4) |
+| 6 | Class cancel policies (G7) — Bathynaut commit / Harpooner crisp | Ratify as design law | ✅ LAW + Bathynaut side SHIPPED (dash refused pre-contact); Harpooner side lands with the Harpooner |
 | 7 | Hades frame-count follow-up session (fill the research gap) | Optional, low priority | ☐ operator |
 
+> Implementation record: [[2026-07-20_Melee_Feel_Forks_B]] (design review `wf_000bc247`: 19 confirmed findings folded in, 5 refuted).
+
 *Checklist for any new attack/ability (the doc in one box):* declare G1 ticks → G2 volume==visual==timing →
 G3 color → G4 loudness tier → G5 impact tier → G6 cast grammar → G7 buffer/cancel policy → (enemy) G8 decal+pose.

Docs/Vault/07_Sessions/2026/2026-07-20_Melee_Feel_Forks_B.md

@@ -0,0 +1,62 @@
+# 2026-07-20 (B) — Melee feel forks 1–6 implemented (guidelines G2/G5/G7)
+
+**Operator approved forks 1–6** of [[Combat_Attack_Feel_Guidelines]]. Feature-track netcode slice → ★ pre-code
+adversarial review (`wf_000bc247`, 3 lenses + per-finding refutation critics: **19 confirmed / 5 refuted**), then
+serial implementation of the review-hardened plan.
+
+## What shipped
+
+**Fork 1 — damage at the contact tick (G2.1).** The server cleave now resolves when the blade LANDS, not at the
+swing press: `MeleeCleavePending` (server-only, baked zeroed on the player) is the AttackWindup schedule-and-consume
+idiom — stamped `SwingStartTick + MeleeTiming.ContactTicks(step, knob)`, fired on a wrap-safe elapsed compare
+(tick-batch-proof), consumed by zeroing, **flushed early if a chained swing would overwrite it** (review C0/C12: no
+knob combination can lose a cleave). Payload builds from LIVE state at fire time (`BuildCleave`) — the cast-turn
+steers the cone until contact. Per-step contacts: 16/10/20t (base knob `MeleeContactTicks` 16, **0 = legacy
+immediate** — the sentinel the mechanics tests pin).
+- Review kills incorporated: the original hashmap latch design (throws on first swing C2/C5; loses chained cleaves
+  C0/C3) was replaced wholesale by the entity-local idiom (C11).
+
+**Fork 2 — reach honesty (G2.2).** `MeleeRange` 2.6 → **2.2 m**; new `MeleeFinisherRangeMult` (**1.25**, knob 30)
+scales finisher REACH only — `MeleeFinisherMult` (1.5) keeps damage/recover/knockback. Arcs (local + remote) use it.
+
+**Fork 3 — weapon + smear (G2.3).** Axe rebaked at **×1.25**; a **blade-smear ribbon** (thin elevated band riding
+the arc's leading edge, `BuildSlashInto` angular-window mode — review C18: one shared builder) plus the ground arc
+whose **sweep-reveal now completes AT the live contact tick** (life derives from the knob per step — review C13;
+remote arcs too).
+
+**Fork 4 — impact ladder (G5), vibrate CUT.** `TryHold(frames)` parameterized (review C17: one hold path);
+finisher-connect holds `FeelConfig.FinisherHoldFrames` (5). **Victim-vibrate was cut**: review C8 verified Rukhanka
+folds the SMR render child's `LocalTransform` INVERSE into the skin matrices — offsetting it does nothing on
+skinned enemies. Follow-up channel: an additive anim layer or bone-space offset.
+
+**Fork 5 — input buffer (G7).** `[GhostField] MeleeCombo.BufferedAttackTick` (predicted, rollback-restored —
+review C9 verified sound): a press in the lock's last `MeleeBufferTicks` (8, knob 29, 0 = off) fires the chain at
+unlock. **Validity anchors to the UNLOCK edge with `MeleeTiming.BatchSlackTicks` (4)** — press-anchored validity
+drops edge presses under the server's default tick-batch of 4 (review C1).
+
+**Fork 6 — the Bathynaut commits (G7).** DashSystem refuses a dash start while a swing is PRE-contact
+(`TickWindowMath.SwingActive` over the contact window — review C15 reuse); post-contact recovery dash-cancel stays.
+Implemented as a **ComponentLookup, not a query add** — a query add would have silently emptied three existing
+dash test suites (review C4).
+
+**Connect-cue honesty (review C14):** the client's melee connect package (bite burst/thunk/FOV kick/rumble/finisher
+hold/arc brighten) moved from the swing edge to the **contact tick** (`EvaluateMeleeConnect`, aim recomputed live).
+
+## Validation
+
+- L1 console error-free. **L2: 414/414** (411 legacy through the pins + 3 new: contact-tick-exactly-once,
+  buffered-chain-at-unlock, dash-law pre/post-contact).
+- **Live server proof** (guardian sampling, injected real attack): SwingStartTick 5968 → pending stamped **5984
+  (= +16)** → enemy HP 200 → 164 **exactly at tick 5984**, pending consumed same tick, no refire; damage 36 = base
+  30 × the Warrior melee seed (live stat folding at resolve ✔). Under observed tick-batching (~4/frame).
+- L3 captures: ×1.25 axe reads; arc + smear track the sweep. Smear re-toned post-capture (thinner band 0.25 rad,
+  innerFrac 0.7, alpha 0.7) — reads as a streak, not a pane; operator eyes-on will fine-tune.
+
+## Wire/bake churn (accepted)
+
+`BufferedAttackTick` GhostField + 3 `DebugTuningReport` fields = ghost + RpcCollection hash change (dev peers
+rebuild together, MPPM same-build); `MeleeCleavePending` baked on Player.prefab (non-replicated); knobs 29–31
+(Count 32); pinned-legacy contract in `MeleeComboTests` (contact 0 / buffer 0 / finRange 1.8).
+
+**Next:** operator eyes/ears-on — cadence (`MeleeContactTicks`/`MeleeRecoverTicks`/`MeleeBufferTicks` knobs),
+smear look, finisher hold weight. DebugOverlay rows for the 3 new knobs = a 5-minute add on request.